Lindsay Lohan vs. Hilary Duff

[likealot]

Hate 'em both.
Hilary is a pozer. she thinks "punk" is just a fashion thing... it's a state of mind, too. A state of mind Hilary will never have.If she wants to see a REAL punk... thats someone like me or my friend Lucinda.... and Lindsay is too well, power hungry. And, also, they're both freaks. Hilary's got a little more "style" but she's still a freak. It's sad what has happend to the label punk, all these people think if they wear ripped fishnets and baggy jeans they're punk... It's just plain SAD.

[kittypurr]

I have a problem with how skinny both are. They both used to be healthy and had nice figures. Now, they are disgustingly thin.

[carly666]

lol For the people who know me, its no competion on who I picked. HILARY ALL THE WAY!!! Texas Girl!

[kittypurr]

I'm glad neither is from the Midwest. Guess if you are from where someone is from, you might support them. Though I could be wrong.

Ehh I don't mind them that much. They're ok.
Hilary is def. not punk.
GC ain't punk either.
And I highly doubt that you guys are punks too.

[carly666]

Yea, Hilary is not punk I can say that much... MAYBE SHE WOULD BE IF THEY WOULD RELEASE SOME OF HER OTHER STUFF!!!!

[likealot]

I dissaggree. Hilary has the wrong attitude to be punk.

[carly666]

Um... yea sure... ok whatever you say... when was the last time you listened to a Hilary CD... all you hear is the stuff her producer picks out.. You wont see "this girl can rock" on TV, you wont see any of the stuff she is really about. Trust me... I know... I have all 3 CD'z

[likealot]

I also have all three CDs. She does have a few good songs, but she just needs to be herself. Not say she is punk.

[kittypurr]

You have her cds? Hmm.

I still say that she can sing, better than Lohan anyways. But whenever I hear her songs on the radio, I turn it off.