The Giver gave me nightmares, more so than Brave New World ever did; well, not nightmares, but unpleasant concepts.
Brave New World, at the very least, had a few amusing parts.
The Giver just made me feel extremely depressed.
I'll Love You Forever could be good as a poem - but the illustrations for it could have been done far, far better and to be fair, yes, does make things look horrifically stalkerish and abusive. meep. o_o