Ohh, I used to have a list like that too, except it was for manga... and it got lost! x D
Everything about Umineko is unique, it'd even make my Narutard brother like it. (became he thinks "Naruto" is the only good anime)
I watched the first couple of episodes of KWMS, it wasn't bad. (but Furuba will always be in my heart!
Never heard of Tiger and Bunny before, is it some sort of ecchi mecha?